Is E120 (Carmine) Halal or Haram?
Cochineal red dye explained: what it is, what scholars say, and how to spot it on labels
e120 halal oder haram · e120 halal ou haram · E120 حلال أم حرام · carmine halal
Verdict Summary
❌ HARAM — According to Most Authorities
E120 is made from crushed cochineal insects. Most halal authorities treat it as haram, though a minority of scholars hold a different view (see below).
What is E120?
E120 is a natural red colouring known as carmine, cochineal or carminic acid. It is produced by drying and crushing female cochineal insects (Dactylopius coccus), which live on cactus plants, mainly in Peru and the Canary Islands. It takes tens of thousands of insects to make a single kilogram of dye.
E120 appears on labels as: E120 · Carmine · Cochineal · Cochineal extract · Carminic acid · Natural Red 4 · CI 75470 · Karmin (German) · Carmin / Cochenille (French) · قرمز / الكارمين
Why Is E120 Considered Haram?
The main reason is its source. Most classical and contemporary scholars hold that insects (other than locusts) are not permissible to eat, and E120 is made directly from the bodies of insects.
- Hanafi, Shafi'i and Hanbali schools: eating insects (other than locusts) is not permissible, so E120 is haram. Halal bodies such as IFANCA and MUI list carmine as haram or non-halal, and JAKIM does not certify products containing E120.
- Maliki school: some Maliki scholars permit eating insects in general, so followers of that school may consider carmine permissible. Other Maliki scholars still rule it impermissible because carmine is not prepared in a way that makes insects fit to eat. This is a minority view.
- External use: some scholars are more lenient for cosmetics that are not eaten, such as blush or eyeshadow. Lipstick is more debated.
Practical advice: If you follow the majority view, treat E120 as haram and look for products coloured with plant-based dyes instead.
Where You Will Find It
| Product Category | Likelihood | Guidance |
|---|
| Red / pink yoghurts and desserts | Common | Check the label; strawberry-coloured products often use it |
| Sweets and candy (red, pink) | Common | Check label; halal-certified sweets avoid it |
| Fruit juices and soft drinks (red) | Sometimes | Look for E120, carmine or cochineal |
| Crab sticks / surimi, red sausages | Sometimes | Used for colour; check label |
| Lipstick, blush and cosmetics | Common | Check ingredients for CI 75470 or carmine |
| Halal-certified products | Rare | Certified products should not contain it |
How to Avoid It
Check the ingredients list for E120, carmine, cochineal, carminic acid, Natural Red 4 or CI 75470. In the EU it must be listed as E120 or by name. In the US, labels must say "cochineal extract" or "carmine".
Halal-friendly red colour alternatives
- E162 Beetroot red — from beetroot
- E163 Anthocyanins — from fruits and vegetables
- E160c Paprika extract — from peppers
- E160d Lycopene — from tomatoes
You can also use the free Afiya AI halal checker to check any colouring by name or E-number.
E120 vs Similar Ingredients — Quick Comparison
| E-Code | Name | Status | Notes |
|---|
| E120 | Carmine / Cochineal | Haram | Made from insects |
| E162 | Beetroot Red | Halal | Plant-based |
| E163 | Anthocyanins | Halal | Plant-based |
| E160c | Paprika Extract | Halal | Plant-based |
| E129 | Allura Red AC | Halal | Synthetic; no animal source |
| E441 | Gelatine | Haram | Usually pork or non-halal beef |
E120 in Other Languages
🇩🇪 E120 Halal oder Haram? (German)
E120 (Karmin, Cochenille) wird aus Schildläusen gewonnen. Die meisten Gelehrten und Zertifizierer stufen es als Haram ein. Eine Minderheit sieht es anders.
e120 halal oder haram · karmin halal · cochenille halal
🇫🇷 E120 Halal ou Haram? (French)
E120 (carmin, cochenille) est fabriqué à partir d'insectes. La plupart des autorités le considèrent comme haram, bien qu'une minorité de savants ait un avis différent.
e120 halal ou haram · carmin halal · cochenille halal
🇳🇱 E120 Halal of Haram? (Dutch)
E120 (karmijn, cochenille) wordt gemaakt van insecten. De meeste autoriteiten beschouwen het als haram, hoewel een minderheid van geleerden een andere mening heeft.
e120 halal of haram · karmijn halal · cochenille halal
🇸🇦 E120 حلال أم حرام؟ (Arabic)
E120 (الكارمين أو القرمز) يُصنع من حشرات مجففة. تعتبره أغلب الجهات حراماً، بينما يرى بعض العلماء خلاف ذلك.
e120 حلال · الكارمين حلال أم حرام · صبغة القرمز
Frequently Asked Questions about E120
Is E120 halal or haram?
Most halal authorities and scholars treat E120 (carmine) as haram because it is made from crushed cochineal insects, and the Hanafi, Shafi'i and Hanbali schools consider eating insects (other than locusts) impermissible. Some Maliki scholars take a more lenient view, but this is the minority position.
What is E120 made from?
E120 is made from dried, crushed female cochineal insects (Dactylopius coccus), which live on cactus plants. It is also called carmine, cochineal and carminic acid.
Is E120 vegan or vegetarian?
No. Because it comes from insects, E120 is not vegan and not suitable for vegetarians who avoid animal products.
What can I use instead of E120?
Plant-based red colourings such as beetroot red (E162), anthocyanins (E163), paprika extract (E160c) and lycopene (E160d) are common alternatives.
Check Any E-Code or Ingredient Instantly
Type any E-code or ingredient name into Afiya AI's free checker and get an instant halal verdict with an explanation and alternatives.
✦ Open Free Halal Checker
Disclaimer: This is a general educational reference. Scholars differ on some points, and halal status can vary by country, manufacturing process and school of Islamic thought. Always verify specific products with your local halal authority or the manufacturer. Afiya AI is not a halal certification body and does not give religious rulings.